Kartavya: Familiar but an important crime thriller/drama

Kartavya written and directed by Pulkit does fall into a tangle with its multiple themes. There is a rushed treatment to the proceedings, nevertheless Kartavya does make for a gripping watch especially the dilemmas faced by Saif Ali Khan’s SHO Pawan Malik. The references to Abhimanyu and Arjuna from Mahabharata does add an interesting dimension.

Starcast: Saif Ali Khan, Sanjay Mishra, Zakir Hussain, Rasika Duggal, Manish Chaudhari, Saurabh Dwivedi etc

Genre: Thriller/drama

Writer and director: Pulkit

Cinematographer: Anil Mehta

Producer: Gauri Khan

Production Company: Red Chillies Entertainment

Running time: 2 hours and 27 minutes

Streaming site: Netflix

The story of Kartavyaa begins on the 40th birthday of Saif Ali Khan’s Pawan Malik. It starts off as a moment of fun camaraderie, a celebration among fellow police men. But soon things take a dramatic turn with the journalist being shot under the vigil of Pawan. This leads to several developments the details of which cannot be revealed here. The movie juggles between the different pressures faced by both Pawan both professionally and personally. Some of the themes explored are caste, abuse of law, the regressive notions of khap panchayat among others

A strong aspect of Kartavyaa are the mythological references. There are numerous dialogues where Pawan compares his situations to Abhimanyu in the Chakravyuh. Later on, there is a parallel to Arjuna’s dilemma’s well. This particularly comes out in connection to the regressive father played by a terrific Zakir Hussain. Harihar is a deeply entranced casteist with fixed notions of so-called societal boundaries. Pawan’s simmering anger and the confrontation scenes with Harihar gives the movie some of its best moments.

The significant role of Khap panchayat’s ideology serving as self-appointed moral custodians has also come out in a disturbing manner. Yes the topic of honor killings has been addressed numerous times in movies but that doesn’t take away its significance in any way. The scenes have a realistic feel sending a chill down the viewers spine.

Rasika Duggal as the homemaker trying to keep things together has a lovely presence. Her scenes with Saif come across as a much-needed breather amidst the tense scenarios. A particular mention must be of the portion where she jokes about Pawan’s smoking while in tension. Some of the other lighter moments include in house references to Shah Rukh Khan as well as Pawan comparing his dad to late Amrish Puri.

Sanjay Mishra as the weary constable is another big asset of the movie. The scenes of on screen friendship between him and Saif has some nice touches. However, an important twist related to his character can be seen from miles.

The corrupt godman and child abuse angle comes with Saurabh Diwidi and Yudhvir Ahlawat. Yudhvir in particular is very effective in the breakdown scenes with Saif. However, Saif Ali Khan is the major glue holding Kartavya together. Saif brings a simmering anger to Pawan, a certain exhaustion both professionally and personally but still a strong fighting spirit has been excellently portrayed by the actor.

As already mentioned Kartavyya does stretch itself a little too far with the themes it wants to explore. As the result there is a sense of incompleteness. A web series along the lines of Sacred Games or Paatal lok would have been a better option.

Also, Kartavyya suffers from a somewhat glossy look. There is a polished feel to the cinematography of Anil Mehta making it a bit distracting.

Final word: Kartavya is worth watching for those who like slow burn thrillers and if you are an admirer of Saif Ali Khan.

The Story of My Assassins: A gripping socio-political thriller about those living on margins

The best part of Tarun Tejpal’s work is the contemporariness of the issues addressed. As a nation we have come a long way still there is much more to do for an equal society. This has come out wonderfully through the stories of the five individuals. The first season of Pataal Lok based on this novel has a few similarities, at the same time it differs too as the web show is from the perspective of Jaideep Ahwalat’s Hathiram

The two seasons of Paatal Lok are easily among the best web shows produced in Indian film industry. The different social themes through an investigative thriller/drama is thoroughly engaging to watch. For those not aware the first season of Paatal Lok was inspired from Tarun Tejpal’s The Story of My Assassins. The novel in brief is about the police stumbling upon five hitmen, they have been hired to assassinate a journalist. This lands as a bombshell forcing the protagonist to reexamine his life. From here the novel shuttles between India’s elite and the hinterland.

An aspect which particularly stands out is how Tarun Tejpal has explored different themes through the five hitmen. Each of them come with a history of generational trauma, persistent abuse and extreme destitution. The readers are forced to confront their own ideas of morality.

The contrast between the protected urban elite and how brutal circumstances creates perpetrators has come out excellently. The theme of institutional failure especially the role of media in today’s society has a lived-in feel. This is majorly thanks to Tarun Tejpal’s vast experience. The soul searching which the protagonist goes through gives the novel some of its best chapters.

The city of Delhi with all its shades has also been well documented. The readers feel that they are travelling with the happenings creating an immersive experience. The different idiosyncrasies has also come out well leading to moments of dry humor.

Among the five hitmen Hathoda Tyagi is definitely the most impactful much like the first season of Paatal lok. There is a quite restraint in the way the man operates. The piercing gaze does more than half of the work. Following is a brilliant paragraph describing Hathoda Tyagi’s character.

The astrologer, his grey hair thick over his ears but gone from the top of his head, said “Oh, don’t start getting worked up. it’s just that, because of his work and strength, he will have powerful foes. You do know mataji that only powerful men have powerful enemies! but it will not be easy to harm him. His stars are like Hiranyakashyap’s. He can only be harmed in a place that has both sunlight and shade; he can only be harmed when he is moving and not still; he can only be harmed when his belly is full; he can only be harmed when he is hidden from view; he can only be harmed by a slain enemy; and he can only be harmed when he is trapped between friends. For all those to come together is a near impossibility. So, you must not worry. Remember, to kill the evil Hiranyakashyap, Lord Vishnu had to appear himself and bend the elements. And as you know gods don’t descend into this country any more.’

Though gripping for a major part The Story of My Assassins has its issues as well. One of them is the women who are mostly presented as an object of violence. They are repeated chapters of them being assaulted. Also, the cop character Hathiram doesn’t have the same impact as the web series.

Keeping aside the deficiencies the novel is an important read especially for those into social thrillers.