Aamir Khan and Co in Sitare Zameen Par
On paper Sitare Zameen Par comes across as well-intentioned normalizing individuals who are dealing with down syndrome and different kinds of autism. However, the problem majorly lies in making the story a redemption arc with too much of Aamir Khan. It doesn’t help that Aamir goes way over the top mimicking his previous performances. This spiritual sequel is an embarrassment to the heart touching Taare Zameen Par
Starcast: Aamir Khan, Simran Mangeskar, Aayush Bhansali, Rishi Shahani, Genelia Deshmukh, Gurpal Singh, Dolly Ahluwalia etc
Genre: Sports
Director: B Prasanna
Writer: Divy Nidhi Sharma
Based on: Champions by Javier Fesser
Producers: Aamir Khan, Aparna Purohit etc
Production Company: Aamir Khan Productions
Music: Shankar Ehsaan Roy
Running time: 2 hours and 35 minutes
Cinematography: G Srinivas Reddy
There is a pivotal moment in Sitare Zameen Par where a team of neurodivergent basketball players have won an important free throw in a game which they could lose. Aamir Khan playing Gulshan is continuously prep talking to a character Satbir (Aroush Datta). After a few minutes Satbir eventually cuts short Gulshan by saying “Sir, pehle aap Chup rahiye,” he says this in a thundering voice shocking Gulshan. This moment aptly sums up the proceedings. After watching Sitare Zameen Par it’s clear that Aamir has learned nothing from the epic disaster Laal Singh Chadda, it’s high time that the actor goes back to the drawing board analyzing his recent style of performances because he is becoming a major roadblock instead of an asset that we are used to seeing in the likes of Rang De Basanti etc.
Taare Zameen Par released in 2007 was a heart touching emotional drama about Darshal Saffery’s Ishaan. A schoolboy suffering from a learning disorder dyslexia and how through an empathetic teacher Ram Shankar Nikumb (Aamir Khan) he overcomes it. The movie brought to light the topic of dyslexia in a sensitive manner. Sitare Zameen Par on the other hand belongs to the rotten template of a coach finding redemption, in the process he overcomes his biases and fears.
Poster of Taare Zameen Par (2007)
Based on a movie called Champions Sitare Zameen Par follows the journey of Aamir Khan’s Gulshan. The film begins by establishing his brash personality, he is suspended for punching the head coach in the initial minutes, this is followed by Gulshan slamming into a police vehicle while being heavily drunk. Instead of jail Gulshan is ordered to do community service, he is ordered to build a team of intellectually challenged persons for the national basketball tournament. The rest of the cliched and exhausting storyline looks at how Gulshan becomes a better human being and also fixes his internal and personal relationships. Genelia Deshmukh plays the estranged wife Suneeta.
Aamir and Genelia
Among very few positives mention must be made of how B Prassana has done justice to the movie tagline Sabka Apna Apna Normal (Everyone has their own normal). The actors playing the intellectually disabled have been chosen with care and that shows on the big screen. Some of the training portions where Aamir is initially exhausted with no idea on how to deal with them does raise chuckles. The ensemble cast particularly Simran Mangeskar, Ayush Bhansali, Rishi Sahani etc do a very fine job getting the mannerisms and the overall body language right. There are a couple of cute moments between Aamir and Simran Mangeskar, for example there is a scene where Gulshan carefully removes onions and capsicum slices from her pizza since the character Golu is allergic to them, similarly there is another moment where Gulshan ties her hair with colorful clips.
Gurpal Singh as the manager of the sports academy lends a lot of warmth to his part specifically in an important conversation with Aamir, it is related to the backstories of these players. Dolly Ahluwalia as the spunky mother has her moments too. Her scenes of banter with Aamir does raise some chuckles. Genelia Deshmukh though in spite of a luminous screen presence is stuck in an underwritten role reduced to a cheerleader for Gulshan’s team.
A major problem with Sitare Zameen Par isn’t just the cliched redemption arc but the way B Prasanna and Divy Nidhi Sharma have tried to assimilate the emotional baggage which Gulshan carries, this eventually makes the movie exhausting particularly in the second half. In trying to give a closure to the characters a thin plot feels like never ending.
It also doesn’t help that Aamir and Genelia have zero chemistry between them. The so-called cute moments simply don’t land. Also, Shankar Ehsaan Loy’s music lacks the heartfelt nature of the first one.
The predictable scenario with endless moral lessons also makes Sitare Zameen Par a tough watch. Aamir Khan as Gulshan pretty much mimics his own previous acts whether it’s the facial expressions or the overall body language. A constant smugness on the face becomes unbearable after a point. The exaggerated tone doesn’t help the matters either like the portion of Gulshan overcoming his fear of lift.
