Tag: Sherlock Holmes

Posted on

Enola Homles 3: A strong anti-colonial thread in a muddled thriller

The third part of this enjoyable franchise has a strong-willed protagonist and a villain modeled on Robin Hood. As an investigative thriller the film lacks the required finesse. There are stretches with the detective elements taking a complete backseat. Having said that the romantic subplot coupled with the political intrigue makes it an enjoyable watch

Starcast: Millie Bobby Brown, Henry Cavil, Louis Patridge, Helena Bonham Carter, Sharon Ducan Brewster and others

Genre: Mystery

Director: Philip Bartani

Screenplay: Jack Thorne

Based on: The novel Enola Holmes Mysteries by Nancy Springer

Producers: Mary Parent, Millie Bobby Brown etc

Production Houses: Legendary Entertainment and PCMA Productions

Cinematography: Matthew Lewis

Running time: 1 hour and 50 minutes

Streaming site: Netflix

Enola Holmes films holds a unique space for its portrayal of feminism in a detective genre. Through the three movies we have a female protagonist going beyond the archaic traditions. In the first two films the viewers saw Enola embarking on various adventures and gradually coming out of her brother Sherlock’s shadow. By the time we come to this part Enola has firmly established her identity as acknowledged by her brother in the closing portions. EH3 is set around the sudden disappearance of Sherlock during Enola’s wedding day. The story in simple terms is about how Enola rescues Sherlock while learning the delicate balance between love, family and a sense of purpose. A political thread running simultaneously is colonialism and how this forces some to become extremists.

A strong aspect of EH 3 is the characterization of actor/producer Millie Bobby Brown. Her character comes with different shades in comparison to the previous ones. Yes, Enola is no longer the impulsive teenager out to prove a point. She has earned respect with her intelligence and courage. Having said that adulthood comes with its own things. Enola’s struggles of balancing her fiercely independent nature, while wanting to settle down with Louis Patridge Tewkesbury gives EH3 some of its best moments. Millie Bobby Brown nails the conflicting emotions making Enola’s coming of age an enjoyable journey.

Louis Patridge as Tewkesbury isn’t reduced to a bystander at any moment. He gets a solid arc of his own especially a crucial revelation about his father’s dark side. The romantic scenes between him and Millie Bobby Brown have some lovely moments with good depth. In short Louis Patridge gives major boyfriend goals with his portrayal of steadfast love.

The dynamics between Sherlock and Enola has also been well done. The climatic portion of Sherlock finally acknowledging Enola as his equal with some heartfelt dialogues pack a solid punch. Henrey Cavil makes a strong impact in this particular stretch.

Another interesting aspect of EH 3 is the political subplot spun around the investigation. Sharon Duncan Brewester playing Moriatary isn’t your stereotypical villain. Her villainy stems from anger towards class privilege and imperial injustice. Yes, Moriatary is ruthless and not likeable having said that her distaste towards colonialism has some valid points.

A major problem with EH 3 is the familiar technique of Enola speaking to the audiences. There was a certain novelty to this technique in the first two parts but here it comes across as laborious. Another issue with EH 3 are the underwritten detective portions.

The juggling act of romantic thread with Enola’s investigation doesn’t blend seamlessly. As a result, the eventual solving doesn’t hit the required high notes. Equal focus on both with a different running time would have benefitted EH 3 more.

Final word: Keeping aside the flaws Enola Holmes 3 makes for a fun weekend watch with a strong feminist aspect.

Posted on

Enola Holmes 1: A worthy successor to Sherlock Holmes

Millie Bobby Brown plays the determined sister with the right mix of feistiness and oodles of charm. Director Harry Bradbeer is successful in setting up an origin story with themes of feminism

Recently I have seen a film called Enola Holmes streaming on Netflix it is the first one in the series of movies focusing on a fictional sister to an already fictional detective. The movie is based on the book The Enola Holmes Mysteries: The case of missing Marquess by Nancy Springer. Millie Bobby Brown plays the central character. Like her brother Sherlock (Henry Cavil) she is extremely intelligent. The mother Eudoria (Helena Bonham Carter) gives her daughter a rather unusual upbringing given the times the film is set in. Through the movie Enola turns out to be an equal firebrand to her already feisty mother. Enola knows many things like deciphering messages that have been written in a secret code along with a Japanese marital art called Jujustu among others. The broad storyline of Enola Holmes 1 is about a young woman becoming a detective to find her missing mother, in the process of finding mother she comes other mysteries too.

The best part of Enola Holmes part 1 is the characterization of the central character coupled with Millie Bobby Brown’s charismatic performance. Throughout the movie she gives a running commentary on what Enola is going through. This could have been irritating in the hands of a mediocre actor, but the dialogues coupled with Millie Bobby Brown’s charm keeps the viewers engaged.

The various disguises of Enola are also charming to watch, often times she dresses up in men’s clothes. This feels like a running gag but at the same time there is a deeper symbolism too. For Enola dressing up in a man’s dress gives her a greater sense of freedom. It allows her to do what she wants without being discovered. How Enola navigates the 19th century patriarchy influenced by her mother is wonderful to watch.

The movie also benefits immensely from the recreation of Victorian England. The CGI coupled with the costume department is absolutely spot on. There is a historical context to the events happening in Enola Holmes. Like a decisive vote over a reform bill.

The different equations of Enola with the brothers also gives the movie some of its best moments. For example, Cavil’s Sherlock is seen mostly cold, but every time Enola outsmarts him there is also a palpable happiness. Apart from Millie Bobby Brown Helena Bonham Carter is also a treat to watch as the revolutionary mother Eudoria.

Posted on

Shekhar Home: Sherlock Holmes with a Bengali twist

This desi rendition is a treat for fans of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s iconic detective. Directors Srijit Mukherjee and Rohan Sippy do a fine job in capturing the eccentric nature of Sherlock Holmes while giving it their own twist. The atmospherics of Kolkata becomes a major character in itself

  • Starcast: Kay Kay Menon, Ranvir Shorey, Rudranil Ghosh, Kaushik Sen, Rasika Dugal, Kriti Kulhari and others
  • Directors: Srijit Mukherjee and Rohan Sippy
  • Creators: Aniruddha Guha and Srijit Mukherjee
  • Inspired by: Arthur Conan Doyle’s Sherlock Holmes
  • Screenplay: Aniruddha Guha Niharika Puri
  • Production house: BBC Studio Productions
  • No of episodes: 6
  • Streaming site: Jio Cinema

The characters of Sherlock Holmes and his associate Dr Watson have captured the imagination of many readers even to this day. The combination of Sherlock Holmes eccentrics and Dr Watson’s more grounded approach makes these stories very entertaining. In Hollywood numerous movies and web shows have taken inspiration from Arthur Conan Doyle’s work. For example, there is the British mystery/ crime series Sherlock. There is also Robert Downey Jr starrer Sherlock Holmes and the sequel Sherlock Holmes: A Game of Shadows. There was also the 2020 Enola Holmes with Millie Bobby as Sherlock Holmes sister. In Indian context you have the character of Byomkesh Bakshi a fictional detective similar to Sherlock Holmes. Shekhar Home has the Bengali atmospherics reminiscent of Byomkesh Bakshi but in tone this detective is closer to Sherlock Holmes whacky nature

Kay Kay Menon and Ranvir Shorey as desi Sherlock Holmes and Dr Watson

The story of Shekhar Home unfolds in a serene town of Lonapur in Bengal. Shekhar (an excellent Kay Kay Menon) is a detective who draws conclusions with his sharp observations. Shekhar’s biggest strength is his perceptive mind and the ability to second guess. Jayavart Saini (Ranvir Shorey) is an ex-army doctor and Shekhar’s new housemate. Together both of them solve many cases ranging from blackmail, murders and also supernatural events. The solving of all these lead to a major revelation in the climax.

The best part of Shekhar Home is its anthology-like structure. Every episode comes with a fresh bunch of suspects, as a result the approach of Shekhar and Jayavart also varies. This makes the show very interesting. The series particularly picks up pace when the action shifts to a place in Bihar. These portions have Jayavart in a stressful mood resulting in some chuckle worthy moments. The task of Shekhar and Jayavart is to catch the person blackmailing a politician. Rasika Dugal plays Iravati, she is a Sitar expert whose observation skills are on par with Shekhar. The chemistry between Kay Kay Menon and Rasika is a delight to watch.

Rasika Dugal in Shekhar Home

Iravati is a seductress with a hidden agenda. The scenes of Shekhar and Iravati using their observation skills to stay one step ahead is wonderful to watch.

Mention also must be made of the segment involving Kriti Kulhari as Mumtaz. Mumtaz is a liaison officer responsible for inter- departmental coordination. Shekhar and Jayavart are on the hunt for a certain M. This segment also keeps you hooked, and the ultimate revelation is indeed a pleasant shocker.

Kriti Kulhari in Shekhar Home

Shekhar Home also benefits from excellent cinematography. The visuals of bustling streets and hidden alleys makes you feel like you are solving the crimes alongside Shekhar. The charm of Kolkata coupled with the eerie mood heighten the tension. The incorporation of the Bengali Folklore is also first rate. Joel Crasto’s background score is in perfect sync. The series ends with a cliffhanger leaving the viewers excited for the second season.

It goes without saying that Kay Kay Menon and Ranvir Shorey shoulder the show with their first-rate performances. Kay Kay slips into the eccentric nature of this desi Sherlock with utmost ease. He portrays the role with the right blend of humor and intensity. Ranvir Shorey as Jayavrat proves to be a perfect partner. Apart from the comic scenes Ranvir particularly shines in the pre climax bringing out an unexpected side of him. Rasika Dugal and Kriti Kulhari also do well in their respective parts. Shehnaz Patel as Shekhar’s landlady comes across as tad too animated which could have been toned down.