Category: Tamil Movie Reviews

Posted on

Viduthalai Part 2: Powerful conclusion but this political tale isn’t everyone’s cup of tea

Viduthalai Part 2 movie image

Director Vetrimaaran continues his politically charged storytelling with themes of oppression, the division of human being on the basis of caste and need to question the flaws in the system. The movie often slips into a highly sermonizing zone but for fans of stories with political undertones this is a must watch

Starcast: Vijay Sethupathi, Manju Warrier, Soori, Rajiv Menon, Kishore and others

Direction and screenplay: Vetrimaaran

Based on: Thunavian by B Jeyamohan and Vengaichami by Thangam

Music: Ilaiyaraaja

Cinematography: R Velraj

Production Companies: RS Infotainment and Grassroot Film Company

Producers: Vetrimaaran and Elred Kumar

Running time: 2 hours and 30 minutes

P A Ranjith and Vetrimaaran are two of the most politically charged filmmakers in mainstream Tamil Cinema. Their movies always feature the suppression of the poor. A very good example of this is Vetrimaaran’s Asuran. It was a powerful take on the caste system making the viewers root for the quest of the central protagonist in protecting his family. The first part of Viduthalai was also a good addition to Vetrimaaran’s filmography. The plot focused on a new joined police personnel Kumeresan played by Soori. As the story progresses he gets caught in the tussle between the police department and the local activist group.

Viduthalai part 1

The movie was highly engrossing engaging the viewers from the first frame with its conflict points. The scenes of police brutality had a very raw nature to it disturbing the audiences. Vijay Sethupati as the leader of the activist group didn’t have a lot of screen time but the national award winner brought in a lot of conviction. Viduthalai part 2 focuses on the events following the arrest of Vijay Sethupati’s Vaathiyar. While the first part was majorly about Soori’s Kumeresan, this time around the narrative focuses on the backstory of Vaathiyar. Before becoming a social crusader Perumal aka Vaathiyar was a normal school teacher. His journey and eventually what happens in the present time forms the core plot of Viduthalai Part 2.

Just like Vetrimaaran’s previous movies here too the major highlight is the hard hitting presentation. The movie focuses on a number of issues taking back the viewers to the times of monstrous zamindars for whom the poor were just meant to be muscled away. A hugely disturbing scene in the first half includes the portion where an evil zamindar rapes a woman who serves him. The events following the heinous incident changes the life of a normal teacher forever.

Similarly the struggles of peasants and how they are exploited touches a raw nerve. The movie also gets into the origin of communism and the movements related to it. The first half also has a romantic subplot between Vijay Sethupati and Manju Warrier. The love story between them has some adorable moments bringing a smile to the viewers face. Manju Warrier’s character is not confined to only romantic scenes, she is also a key member of the party with an agency of her own. In the beginning portions she is seen sporting short hair for a particular reason which can’t be revealed here.

Vijay Sethupathi and Manju Warrier in Viduthalai part 2

The movie also talks about how the activists can also go the wrong way with violence never being a permanent solution. Mention must also be made of the scenes in which the authorities are seen trying to cover up their failures or trying to give a new spin.

What pulls down the movie though is a certain sense of repetition. At times the movie keeps circling around similar themes with heavy sermonizing. This results in a certain fatigue particularly for those who aren’t into politically charged storytelling. More brevity was needed, also Kumaresan’s coming of age would have had more impact with better writing.

Soori is largely relegated to the sidelines making the viewers miss his presence. Soori does make his presence amply felt in spite of the limited screen time but the impact of the first part is diluted here. The movie could also have done with crisper dialogues at some points.

As Vaathiyar Vijay Sethupati pulls the characters transformation with his trademark finesse. He captures the simmering anger, empathy and certain remorse too in an impactful manner. Manju Warrier is suitably feisty proving to be a worthy comrade. She also brings a certain softness to the romantic scenes. Among the rest Rajiv Menon plays a powerful bureaucrat in an authoritative manner.

Vijay Sethupati as Vaathiyar in Viduthalai part 2

R Velaraj’ds cinematography is of the highest order. Particular mention must be made of the battles between the police personnel and the extremist groups in the dense forests. The music of the legendary Illaiyaraja is quite soulful with songs of different nature whether it is the tender love song between Vijay Sethupati and Manju Warrier or the more intense one perfectly capturing the resistance.

To sum it up Vidhulathai is a must watch for those who like Vetrimaaran’s storytelling and have an inclination towards intense political dramas.

Posted on

Amaran: A well-made war drama with an outstanding Sivakarthikeyan

Amaran ticks all the boxes of a typical army movie. As viewers you know where the film is headed still the tight writing coupled with the performances make it an engaging watch. Sai Pallavi as Indu Rebecca Varghese adds an emotional depth to her mostly one note character
  • Starcast: Sivakarthikeyan, Sai Pallavi, Bhuvan Arora, Rahul Bose, Geetha Kailasam and others
  • Direction and screenplay: Rajkumar Periyaswamy
  • Additional screenplay: Stefan Richer
  • Based on: India’s Most Fearless: True Stories of Modern Military Heroes
  • Producers: Kamal Haasan, R Mahendran and Vivek Krishnani
  • Production Companies: Raaj Kamal Films International and Sony Pictures Films India
  • Cinematography: CH Sai
  • Music: GV Prakash Kumar
  • Running time: 2 hours and 49 minutes

Rajkumar Periyaswamy’s Amaran follows a certain template particularly the beats of Adavi Sesh’s Major. Just like the protagonist of Major here too the hero Mukund decides at an early age that he will join the army. Unlike both parents who are not happy with their son’s decision in Major, here the father is quite supportive. The mother though prays to God that he should fail the army test which of course doesn’t happen. There is also the angle of the future in laws who are dead against their daughter marrying an army man. The death of Major Mukund while battling a deadly enemy is also something that the viewers can see from a mile. In spite of the predictable scenarios Amaran touches an emotional chord particularly for those coming from army families. Even if you aren’t a fan of movies with army background Amaran is still enjoyable.

Amaran follows a certain template particularly the beats of Adavi Sesh’s Major

Amaran is told from the perspective of Major Mukund’s wife Indu Rebecca Varghese (an excellent Sai Pallavi). How love blossomed between them in Madras Christian college. Indhu has a major stage fear which Mukund helps her overcome. The movie plays like a series of flashbacks showing the different facets of Mukund as a son, lover, husband, father alongside his various roles in the army.

Sivakarthikeyan and Sai Pallavi in Amaran

The heart of Amaran is the love story and the director has done a wonderful job in showcasing the various stages of the relationship. The tender moments between Mukund and Indhu make the viewers wish that the real-life story had panned out differently. A couple of scenes worth mentioning here are the one where Mukund leans on Indhu’s shoulder saying that he didn’t think military training would be this tough and wants to sleep on her shoulders for a while. Similarly, there is an adorable video call where Mukund calms down Indhu’s tensions making her temporarily forget the kilometers of distance between them.

Mention must also be made of the dynamics between Indhu and Geeta Kailasam’s Geetha Varadarajan. Initially Geeta is dead against their marriage and even tries to sabotage the relationship but soon they become thick friends. The commonality between them is the pain of separation and the underlying love for Mukund.

A major portion of Mukund’s military life is set amidst the backdrop of political insurgency in Kashmir. The numerous battles of CRPF in dealing with the militant outfits has been well documented. There are scenes of Indian army working closely with the camps of ex militants wanting to start a fresh life. A few members of the Kashmiri youth are also seen working in the Indian army which doesn’t go down well with a certain community.

There are lines hinting on how the tension filled atmosphere is due to the people sitting in the government. The film also gives a brief glimpse into the emotional turmoil of the militant families. However, the presentation of Kashmir conflict needed greater depth. At the end of day Rajkumar Periyaswamy reduces the decades long upheaval to a superficial good versus bad saga. For example, the scenes of stone pelting are shown to be an act of terrorism ignoring the fact that it is also a form of protest. In its quest to honor Mukund’s bravery the political complexity of the issue is sidetracked.

Talking about the fights the movie has some well-choreographed combat sequences like the scene where Mukund’s fellow army man cum friend leaps on to a grenade with only a wooden board as a shield. Even the pre climax of Mukund battling with the enemy in a confined space is thrilling. Cinematographer CH Sai deserves distinction marks for a job very well done. He does a wonderful job in capturing both the scenic beauty of Kashmir and also the ambush sequences. GV Prakash Kumar’s background score is another asset for the movie particularly in the action sequences. The songs are quite melodious.

The role of major Mukund is truly a game changer for Sivakarthikeyan. It is vastly different from what he usually does, he springs a very pleasant surprise transforming from a boy next door in the initial portions to a brave army man. The best part of Sivakarthikeyan’s performance is how he manages to convey a certain sense of vulnerability and humanness underneath the tough exterior. For example, there is a scene in the second half where he tears up pleading with the senior officer by Rahul Bose. Sai Pallavi as already mentioned plays a mostly one note character a constant cheerleader for the husband however adverse the circumstances are. In the hands of a weak actor Indhu would have been annoying but given Sai Pallavi’s acting prowess she adds a lot of emotional depth with her nuanced act. She is particularly good in the breakdown scene post Mukund’s death.

Sivakarthikeyan as the brave army man
Sai Pallavi adds a lot of emotional depth with her nuanced acting

The supporting cast comprises of actors in small yet significant parts. Geeta Kailasam as the mother makes a striking impact. Among the actors playing Mukund’s colleagues Bhuvan Arora does a wonderful job. Rahul Bose as the senior officer brings in the required authority and a sense of empathy. Talking about Mukund’s scenes with the colleagues a mention must be made of the portion where Mukund and his fellow men discuss about movies with references to Thuppakki and Fahadh Fassil. The camaraderie has come out well.

To sum it up Amaran makes for a satisfying war drama in spite of some glitches.

Posted on

Vettaiyan: The triumph of stardom over storytelling

At its core director TJ Gnanvel has an important story to say, the dangers of hurried justice resulting from external pressure and sufferings of the poor but the struggle to balance the societal aspects with the demands of Rajinikanth fans make it an uneven film at best

  • Starcast: Rajinikanth, Amitabh Bachchan, Fahadh Faasil, Rana Daggubati, Manju Warrier, Ritika Singh and others
  • Director and writer: TJ Gnanvel
  • Additional writer: B Kiruthika
  • Producer: Subaskaran Allirajah
  • Music: Anirudh Ravichander
  • Cinematography: SR Kathir
  • Production Company: Lyca Productions
  • Running time: 2 hours and 45 minutes

T J Gnanvel’s last movie Jai Bhim was a hard-hitting tale on the horrors of custodial torture. It was by no means an easy watch particularly the portions involving police atrocities, but still the relevancy of those scenes shook the viewers conscience. Jai Bhim rightfully won many awards along with garnering excellent ratings. What also made Jai Bhim a major winner was the use of Suriya’s stardom. The actors star power at no point overpowered the narrative, Suriya also blended in perfectly delivering his lines with absolute conviction. Vettaiyan directed by the same TJ Gnanvel’s also focuses on the sufferings of poor people showcasing the transformation of an encounter specialist while merging the topic of educational scams. But unlike Jai Bhim here the director’s handling of the subject leaves a lot to be desired. Vettaiyan isn’t a complete washout particularly if you are a diehard Rajinikanth fan, but the movie leaves you with the feeling that it could have been so much more given the names associated.

Vettaiyan isn’t a complete washout particularly if you are a diehard Rajnikanth fan

Vettaiyan primarily focuses on the vastly different ideologies of SP Athiyan (Rajinikanth) and a prominent lawyer cum human rights activist Sathyaraj (Amitabh Bachchan). SP Athiyan is popularly known as an encounter specialist. He is a no- nonsense police officer who prefers the method of extrajudicial killings in order to deliver speedy justice. Sathyaraj is a vocal critic of SP Athiyan’s methods. Sathyaraj firmly believes that speedy justice is not the way to go about things. For him it is as bad as delaying cases for years in court. Fahadh Faasil is Patrick. He is a thief turned police informer with a lot of technical knowledge. His knowledge regarding the technical aspects makes him a very valuable addition. SP Athiyan’s firm belief on speedy justice takes a major hit when an innocent person dies. He is forced to reconsider his ideals marking a significant change in the thought process. This is the story in brief.

Vettaiyan primarily focuses on the vastly different ideologies of SP Athiyan (Rajinikanth) and a prominent lawyer cum human rights activist Sathyaraj (Amitabh Bachchan)

Through Vettaiyan director TJ Gnanvel has focused on multiple social issues whether it is encounter killings to satisfy a mob or the business of education, particularly exams like NEET. All of this while trying to merge Rajinikanth’s stardom. This khichdi doesn’t come across satisfactorily and a major reason for that it is the confused tone.

The first half is filled with numerous scenes of Rajinikanth carrying out his own form of justice against the backdrop of Anirudh Ravichander’s stylized background score. These are very repetitive in nature tiring the audiences quickly. What also makes the proceedings silly is the reason behind SP Athiyan’s wife played by Manju Warrier to not have children. There is a scene where Athiyan talks about the wife not wanting children as she believes it is a form of sacrifice for her husband killings. It is a very flimsily written scene leaving no impact whatsoever.

Yes, the inevitable transformation in SP Athiyan does take place in the second half. There are few scenes exploring the guilt that SP Athiyan faces, but TJ Gnanvel doesn’t let those moments linger. From the middle of second half the movie gets into the usual zone of good versus evil. Rana Daggubati plays a typical corporate villain who feeds on the poor. The actor has a towering presence but suffers majorly on the account of a sketchy characterization. It looks he had directly entered from Baahubali sets to this.

Amitabh Bachchan as Sathyaraj though makes his presence amply felt. Sure, the characterization lacks the meat of what Nag Ashwin pulled off with the Shahenshah in Kalki 2989 AD. But still the senior actor brings in a much-needed gravitas in the scenes where he talks about unequal society and the poor generally being the causalities of encounter killings. Rajinikanth as SP Athiyan is mostly required to be a star which the actor pulls off with consummate ease but there isn’t much in the role for the actor Rajini to shine.

Fahadh Faasil as Patrick raises many chuckles with his antics. He brings in a certain energy perfectly embodying the required street smartness. There is also a slight emotional touch in a crucial scene with Rajinikanth making the viewers feel for Patrick.

Fahadh Faasil as Patrick raises many chuckles with his antics. He perfectly embodies the street-smart nature

Anirudh’s music once again after Devara is a major misfire. Working on too many projects is clearly affecting the quality of this young talented musician. The background score though slightly better becomes monotonous after a point.

A major problem of Vettaiyan are also the investigative portions of the second half. The pattern of investigation and the eventual reveal of Rana being the big villain becomes easy to guess leaving little to no surprises. The hero and villain clash also becomes heavily one sided.

To sum it up Vettaiyan wants to be both a commercial entertainer and also a serious movie, but it eventually ends up in the zone of nowhere. A major letdown from the director of Jai Bhim.

Posted on

Thangalaan: Pa Ranjith’s movie feels like an arthouse subject force fitted into a pan India cinema

Pa Ranjith continues his repertoire of politically charged storytelling, but overdose of magic realism coupled with many symbolisms make it a very tedious watch

  • Starcast: Vikram, Parvathy Thirovuthu, Malavika Mohanan, Pasupathy, Daniel Caltagorine and others
  • Direction story and screenplay: Pa Ranjith
  • Additional screenplay and story: Azhagiya Periyavan and Tamil Prabha
  • Music: GV Prakash Kumar
  • Production Companies: Studio Green and Neelam Productions
  • Running time: 2 hours and 15 minutes

Pa Ranjith’s Thangalaan feels like a prequel to Prashant Neel’s massive hits KGF 1 and 2. Through this movie Pa Ranjith has showcased the origin of gold mining in the Kolar Gold Fields. Pa Ranjith is known for depicting socially relevant issues using big stars as a medium – case in point are the two movies made with Rajnikanth Kabali and Kaala. The latter in particular was an impactful movie. In this film too Pa Ranjith talks about the lower caste people deprived of their lands first by the landlords and then by the British who promise to give them dignity. Thangalaan would have been a good addition to Pa Ranjith’s repertoire if he had struck to the core plot, but unnecessary addition of magic realism coupled with a confusing screenplay make it an extremely boring movie. The film has its moments like the scene where the women wear blouses for the first time. Malavika Mohanan springs a pleasant surprise with her intense portrayal of a warrior woman, Parvathy Thirovuthu as Gangamma also delivers a praiseworthy act, but these aren’t enough to save this overstuffed movie.

Malavika Mohanan springs a very pleasant surprise

The story of Thangalaan focuses on a tribe of people making a living from agriculture. Vikram plays the central character. Thangalaan is haunted by certain visions of a warrior goddess Aarthi (Malavika Mohanan). Parvathy plays Thangalaan’s wife Gangamma. Pasupathy is another key member of the tribe. His role has a major aspiration of reaching Vaikuntam through Ramanuja’s teachings. His character is often used for generating humor. Things take an interesting turn when an Englishman Lord Clement (Daniel Caltagorine) asks the villagers to help him in locating the gold mines. Thangalaan firmly believes that gold will bring a positive transformation in their lives. Additionally, Lord Clement also promises a share in the gold along with a better standard of living, Thangalaan foolishly believes this. Locating the gold is easier said than done as a warrior woman was supposed to protect the area. This is the story in brief.

The positives in Thangalaan can be counted on the tip of one’s fingers. Malavika Mohanan as Aarthi is definitely one of them. Malavika is mostly known for her hot image but here the actress sheds all vanity getting into the skin of the role. There is a palpable anger in her eyes. Throughout the movie Aarthi makes more sense than the central character. Along with anger a certain concern is also there for Thangalaan. She constantly reminds him that he is not doing right. Malavika does an extremely good job in portraying these facets. Parvathy Thirovuthu is the feisty wife who doesn’t back down from confronting her husband when needed. Parvathy’s acting skills doesn’t need any specific introduction and here too she makes the viewers feel the emotional turmoil of Gangamma.

Parvathy as the feisty wife

One of the few memorable scenes in Thangalaan is the scene where the women wear blouses for the first time. There is a certain wonder in their eyes that is fun to watch. The song and dance sequence that follows makes for a good moment, a much-needed relief from the heavy bloodshed.

A major issue with Thangalaan is the characterization of Vikram. As an actor Vikram gave his usual hundred percent, but the characterization lets Vikram down. Thangalaan’s belief in Lord Clement having genuine empathy towards them feels terribly misplaced. He becomes the major reason for the tribe’s suffering, putting their life at stake ignoring Aarthi’s warnings. It is hard to think of Thangalaan as a leader, more so when he doesn’t listen to his own kin in spite of people dying around him. This sketchy characterization hampers the movie in a major way. The best example of this is the pre- climax where Thangalaan finally shows repentance but by then the damage has already been done.

As an actor Vikram gives his usual hundred percent

Thangalaan also suffers from way too much abstractness. There is a constant crosscut between Thangalaan’s visions of his ancestors and the present day. This juggling act adds to the viewers impatience. It becomes hard to follow the storyline because of it. Additionally, GV Prakash’s background music threatens to break audience’s ears. It is too loud and jarring.

To sum it up Thangalaan is Pa Ranjith’s Raavan (Mani Ratnam movie) moment. It is a massive downfall for a respected filmmaker who gave Rajinikanth one of his best movies Kaala. Watch it only if you are a die-hard Pa Ranjith or Vikram fan.

Posted on

Raayan: Solid performances along with the technical department elevate a familiar saga of gangster wars and a protective brother

Dhanush does a good job in establishing the emotional bond of the siblings particularly the strong characterizations of Sundeep Kishan and Dushara Vijayan

  • Starcast: Dhanush, Sundeep Kishan, Kalidas Jayaram, Dushara Vijayan, S.J. Suryah, Prakash Raj, Aparna Balamurali and others
  • Director and writer: Dhanush
  • Music: A. R. Rahman
  • Production Company: Sun Pictures
  • Cinematography: Om Prakash
  • Running time: 2 hours and 25 minutes

Dhanush is one of those few actors who is both a bankable star along with being a fantastic performer. His name comes with a certain weightage. Raayan is Dhanush’s 50th movie, naturally there are some expectations of it being a solid one. Raayan is also the second movie directed by Dhanush after Pa. Pandi.

For his second venture Dhanush has chosen an emotional story of four siblings who flee from their village and come to the city of North Chennai. Raayan (Dhanush) is the elder one. The youngest one is Manickam (Kalidas Jayaram). The second youngest is Muthu (Sundeep Kishan). Durga (Dushara Vijayan) is the sister, she is the binding factor. All the four have their own distinct qualities. Their lives undergo a drastic change when Raayan finds himself sandwiched in a power struggle between two gangsters Sethu (SJ Suryah) and Durai (Saravanan). There is also a new cop in town played by Prakash Raj. Prakash Raj wants to turn the two gangsters against each other so that the city will become clean. This is the story in brief

Dhanush has chosen a strong emotional story of four siblings

There is no denying that Raayan gives a major deja vu of some previous movies set in the gangster milieu. Even the stoic nature of Raayan is far from novel. The viewers can predict the violent persona of Raayan that will eventually come through. However, what makes the movie somewhat engaging are sibling dynamics that come with a few unexpected twists and turns. Dhanush has made sure that the movie doesn’t become a one- man show.

Sundeep Kishan as Muthu gets a chance to display a wide spectrum of emotions and the actor doesn’t disappoint. The way he portrays the emotional turmoil of Muthu during a key sequence of the second half in particular deserves a lot of praise. Dushara Vijayan has a very meaty part never reduced to a doormat sister. Dushara Vijayan portrays her fiery character in an excellent manner. She even upstages Dhanush in some sequences.

Sundeep Kishan as Muthu gets a chance to display a wide spectrum of emotions

As Raayan Dhanush is mostly seen in a brooding manner, he emotes through his eyes and overall body language. Dhanush’s role of a protector is similar to the one already done in Asuran, nevertheless the actor impresses with his trademark intensity. Selvaraghavan also makes for a perfect guardian with his calm demanor.

Dushara Vijayan has a very meaty part and not reduced to a doormat sister

Om Prakash’s cinematography goes perfectly well with the mood of the movie. His frames perfectly capture the dangers lurking around. A. R Rahman’s music and background score also elevate the movie in many places. My favorite song of the album is “Uusure Nee Thaane,” this comes in the first half and perfectly captures the emotional bond among the siblings.

A major drawback for Raayan is the lack of development in Prakash Raj’s role. He gets a grand entry but ends up being a mere puppeteer in the larger scheme of things. His mind games are thoroughly uninspiring to say the least. He never comes across as an authoritative figure which was the need of the role. The film’s action while thrilling to watch also feels overdone after a point. The constant slashing and bone crunching makes the movie look like an assemblage of violent scenes. However, an action sequence in hospital where Dushara Vijayan takes on the bodies deserves distinction marks for the way it has been choreographed.

The story’s basic arc is of betrayal and revenge, something done to death. As a result, the viewers feel no major high at the end of the movie.

To sum it up Raayan doesn’t completely match the high standards that Dhanush has set for himself.

Posted on

Jailer: A Well Packaged Entertainer

There are enough Rajini moments to keep the fans satisfied
Jailor ( Tamil). 3 out of 5
Starcast: Rajinikanth, Vinayakan, Ramya Krishna, Yogi Babu and others special appearances ( Shiv Rajkumar, Mohanlal and Jackie Shroff)
Director and writer: Nelson Dilipkumar
Producer: Kalanithi Maran
Production Company: Sun Pictures
Music: Anirudh Ravichander
Genre: Action/comedy
Running time: 2 hours and 48 minutes

Jailer, directed by Nelson Dilipkumar, is a commercial potboiler with a mix of everything. There is the father and son emotion with a climax that is reminiscent of Kamal Haasan’s Bharateeyudu. There is also lot of dark humour generated through Yogi Babu’s character. The film takes the viewers back to Baasha times. Like in Baasha the protagonist in this film also has a violent past.

The film begins with the introduction of a gang who smuggles temple sculptures. The head of gang is Varman (Vinayakan). The opening scene establishes the brutality of the antagonist. From here we move to Tiger Muthuvel Pandian (Rajinikanth). Pandian is a retired jailor who now spends most of his time making YouTube videos with his grandson. His son Arjun (Vasanth Ravi) is an assistant commissioner of police who is on the trail of Varman’s gang. Arjun is warned by many not to dig too deep into this case but he refuses to stop the investigation. One day Arjun goes missing and the viewers are led to believe that he is dead. But things are not as simple as they appear to be. In brief Jailor is about what happened to Arjun and how Muthuvel Pandian nullifies the baddies with the help of some delightful cameos.

For any masala potboiler it is necessary that the villain is on par with the hero. Jailor doesn’t disappoint you there. Nelson has created a terrific antagonist with the character of Vinayakan. Vinayakan makes a huge impression with just his body language. Even in the lighter moments the actor does a very good job. A special mention must be made of Harshath playing one of the henchmen. In spite of limited screen time he makes a good impact.

Rajinikanth and others in celebration mood

The family moments particularly those between Rajinikanth and his on-screen grandson leave a smile on the viewers face. There is palpable warmth between them.  

The dark humour in the film mostly lands thanks to Yogi babu’s comic timing and the banter that both he and Rajinikanth share. Even the action scenes have a certain element of fun.

Coming to Rajinikanth’s Muthuvel Pandian Nelson has done a good job in designing the character. Initially we see Rajinikanth underplaying but later the character transforms into a menacing force. This has been showcased well. The emotional bits are also done well. There are scenes where there are no dialogues but the emotion is still very much felt.

Vinayakan, the perfect villain

Anirudh’s music and background score is another strong pillar for the film. It elevates the scenes in a major way. My favorite song in the film is Rathamaarey which showcases the family bond.

Finally the cameos have also been integrated well. It is a treat to watch Rajinikanth sharing screen space with Mohanlal and Shiv Rajkumar.

What doesn’t work for Jailor is the subplot of Sunil and Tamannah. It only adds to the length of the second half. Ramya Krishna as a typical housewife plays her part well but some of Rajinikanth’s scenes with her come across as too misogynistic.

Keeping the flaws aside it is good to see Rajinikanth playing his age like Amitabh Bachchan. Hope more good stories are written for him.

Posted on

PS-2: A More Focused Film Than Part 1

In spite of the flaws director Mani Ratnam deserves credit for bringing alive a relatively unknown part of history

PS 2(Tamil) 3 out of 5

  • Starcast: Vikram, Jayam Ravi, Karthi, Aishwarya Rai Bachchan, Jayaram, Rehman, Trisha and others
  • Direction and screenplay: Mani Ratnam
  • Additional screenplay: B. Jeyamohan and Elango Kumaravel
  • Story: Kalki Krishnamurthy
  • Based on: Ponniyin Selvan by Kalki Krishnamurthy
  • Producers: Mani Ratnam and Subaskaran Allirajah
  • Production companies: Madras Talkies and Lyca productions
  • Genre: Historical drama
  • Running time: 2 hours and 45 minutes

Kalki Krishnamurthy’s novel on the Chola dynasty is considered to be a significant part of Tamil literature. The novel Ponniyin Selvan was also serialized in the weekly editions of a Tamil magazine. PS-1 (Ponniyin Selvan) was Mani Ratnam’s dream project which finally came alive in 2022. Not surprisingly PS-1 worked more in the Tamil belt given the nativity factor. The film had a mixed response in other languages particularly the Hindi market.

It did decently well in Telugu also but in Hindi the film didn’t attract many eyeballs. A big shortcoming of PS-1 was its convoluted screenplay coupled with the addition of too many subplots. There were also some editing lags.

Hence the anticipation around PS-2 was not the same as SS Rajamouli’s Bahubaali 2. However a Mani Ratnam directorial always garners attention even though the director has not been in his best form of late.

The second part begins at the exact point where the first part ended. The Cholas led by Arunmozhi Varman aka Ponniyin Selvan (Jayam Ravi), brother of Chola king Aditya Karikaludu and Vallavaraiyan Vandhiyadevudu (Karthi) are fighting with Pandyas in the sea. While fighting they fall into the waters. Fortunately, they are saved by a mute woman Mandakini (Aishwarya Rai Bachchan in a double role). Later Arunmozhi gets treated by the Buddha monks in Sri Lanka. At the same time a conspiracy is taking place. Nandini (again Aishwarya Rai Bachchan) along with the Pandyas is planning to eradicate the Chola dynasty. There are also some Chola chieftains who want to make Madhuranthakudu (Rehman) the Chola king by dethroning Aditya Karikaludu (Vikram).

The rest of the film deals with how the power struggle maps out. And also who is Mandakini and what is her connection with Nandini? Do Arunmozhi and Vallavaraiyan Vandhiyadevudu return to the Chola kingdom? And lastly, who gains the upper hand- Cholas or Pandyas?

First and foremost – the screenplay of PS-2 is a definite improvement over the first part. Mani Ratnam does a good job in connecting all the loose ends and coming up with satisfactory answers.

Some of the twists and turns do catch the viewers unaware. A particular mention must be made of the Nandini’s back story.

The dramatic scenes in PS-2 have also been far better written. A good example of that is the love hate relation between Aditya Karikaludu and Nandini. Vikram and Aishwarya don’t have many scenes together, but the intensity is very much palpable in the brief encounters that they have. There is an important sequence late in the second half featuring the two. This scene does pierce the audience’s heart thanks to the direction and also the performances of Vikram and Aishwarya. Vikram in particular is brilliant with certain unhingedness.

Vikram and Aishwarya do not have many scenes together, but the intensity is very much palpable

As Nandini Aishwarya does a good job in bringing out the dilemmas that her character goes through. Nandini isn’t very likeable person but at the same time you don’t hate her completely either. It also does help that Nandini has a certain charm about her which Aishwarya portrays effortlessly. As Mandakini though she does fall short majorly due to the way the character has been written.

As Nandini Aishwarya Rai Bachchan does a very good job in bringing out the dilemmas that her character goes through.

The romantic scenes between Karthi and Trisha’s Kundavai have a classic Mani Ratnam stamp. There is a scene in the island where Karthi’s character is blindfolded, and subtle romance follows between the two.

Karthi and Trisha romance

As Vandhiyadevudu Karthi continues from where he left off in the first part. He not only provides entertainment with his antics, but also shows his all-round capability in the more emotional scenes. Jayam Ravi brings out the required authority. He commands our attention with his mere presence.

As Vandhiyadevudu Karthi successfully takes off from where he left in the first part
Jayaram Ravi brings out the required authority

Technically PS- 2 is as rich as the first one. The production design by Aparna Thota Tharani is fantastic. The production design enhances the work of the cinematographer Ravi Varma. He does a good job in showcasing the scale of the film through his lens. The VFX department also does a fair job.

Coming to the shortcomings PS 2 feels super stretchy as the first part. The run time of 2 hours and 50 minutes does feel quite long more so with the severely underwhelming battle scenes. The battle scenes have been rather clumsily staged and doesn’t provide the viewers with any high.

The portions featuring Jayaram is reduced to a stock comic character. Even the likes of Prakash Raj and Sarath Kumar suffer on the account of ineffective characterizations.

The film has also got some unnecessary slow mo. moments and close up shots that end up irritating the audiences more than giving an extra edge.

In spite of these flaws Maniratnam deserves credit for exploring a relatively unknown part of history on pan India screen. And in this he is aided by some good performances along with the technical team.

PS-2: A more focused film than part 1

Posted on

Ponniyan Selvan Part 1 – More Of A Docu Drama Than A Historical Epic

The genre of big scale epics has seen a huge revival thanks to filmmakers like Sanjay Leela Bhansali, SS Rajamouli and even Ashutosh Gowariker to an extent. The likes of Bajirao Mastani, Bahubali 1 and 2 and Jodha Akbar have created a deep impact in the audiences mind. With Ponniyin Selvan Part 1 legendary director Mani Ratnam attempts a genre which he has never done in the past. For those who are not aware the movie is based on a novel by the same name. Since I have not read the novel I will be purely judging the movie as a standalone piece.

Ponniyin Selvan tries to be a gripping combination of thrills, intrigue and emotions.  However, in its effort to be plot heavy the film ends up being neither here nor there, particularly for the Telugu and Hindi audiences.

The story is majorly centered on the character of Vanthiyathevan (Karthi) he is entrusted by Aditya Karikaaludu (Vikram) with the task of delivering important messages to Karikaaludu’s father and sister (Prakash Raj and Trisha respectively). As per the messages plans are being laid out by princely kings to bring down the Chola Empire. Vanithiyathevan’s duty is to find out what are the evil plans and who are hell bent on tarnishing the glory of the Chola Empire. Aishwarya Rai plays princess Nandini. Nandini is someone who comes with a mysterious past, this mysterious past is connected to Karikaaludu. Other important characters include Jayam Ravi as Ponniyin Selvan.

What follows is a complex drama that is hard to keep up with.

One of the few redeeming factors of PS-1 is some of the performances starting with Karthi. The actor is a delight to watch whenever he is on screen. His comic timing and the general energy that he brings to the screen is something that uplifts the film at many places. His interactions with both Aishwarya and Trisha bring a smile to your face.

Vikram as Karikaaludu has less screen time but the actor’s intense performance is a treat to watch. Jayram Ravi makes his entry in the second half but the actor makes his presence amply felt.

Both Aishwarya Rai Bachchan and Trisha look like million bucks thanks to director Mani Ratnam and the costumes by Eka Lakhani. Mani Ratnam along with Sanjay Leela Bhansali are one of those few directors who best understand how to use Aishwarya. Here too Mani Ratnam casts her smartly as the enigmatic queen with her own secrets.

Cinematography by Ravi Varman also goes perfectly with the requirement of the film. He does a good job in showing the grandeur of Cholas through his lens. The production design by Thota Tharrani also adds to the richness of the frames.

The biggest issue with Ponnin Selvan- 1 is the numerous subplots integrated into the story by the director. Too many things are happening simultaneously and as a result it is difficult to catch up the plot.

The film is also filled with many characters that don’t make any impact whatsoever. Perfect examples of these are ones played by Prakash Raj, Sarat Kumar and Rehman.

The film’s editing is also subpar as the drama moves at a very slow pace, particularly in the second half. Some of the scenes are way too lengthy. A perfect example of this is the climax where Karthi and Jayam Ravi take upon some villains. The fight scene happens in a ship with thundering rain as a backdrop. It is definitely jaw dropping but this action block goes on way too long. Because of this the cliff hanger at the end doesn’t really make an impact.

Music by AR Rahman is pleasant but nothing spectacular. It is nowhere close to their previous associations.

Final word: Watch PS-1 if you are a fan of Mani Ratnam or you like slow paced historical dramas. The rest can give it a skip.

Posted on

Gargi : Only For Die Hard Fans Of Sai Pallavi

Gargi directed by Gautam Ramachandra is a khichdi of many films. Courtroom drama interspersed with an important social topic has become a genre in itself. Case in point being Surya’s Jai Bheem and Prithviraj Sukumaran’s Jana Gana Mana among others. The topic of sexual abuse is also something which we have seen in films earlier too. A film becomes engaging only when a director brings something new to the table even within the familiar zone. Gautam did try to make it engaging but he did not succeed completely. One thing is sure, the twist at the end is something which knocks off your feet.

(Sai Pallavi) is a school teacher leading a decent life in Hyderabad. Her father (R.S Shivaji) is a security guard. He is accused of sexual abuse on a girl child, this girl child lives in the apartment that he works. Gargi is convinced that her father is innocent and she wants to prove it. No lawyer is ready to fight his case as everyone is convinced that the security guard is indeed guilty. At this crucial juncture an inexperienced advocate Gireeshan Kappaganthula (Kaali Venkat) steps in. Adding to the mix there is also Aishwarya Lekmi playing a typical version of cinema journalist. The rest of the story is about whether the security guard has been falsely accused or if he has actually done this heinous crime.

Gautam Ramachandra doesn’t waste any time in setting up the plot. More than the story it is the narration that pulls you in. The director does a good job in capturing the lifestyle of Gargi and her surroundings. There is no artificiality here.

The portions between Sai Pallavi and Kaali Venkat have also been well developed by the director. The way he comes forward to help Gargi has come out well. There is also some subtle humour that he brings to the table.

The director also deserves credit for creating the character of a transgender judge. Sudha S brings a certain authority to the part. She is particularly good when she gives it back to the public prosecutor after his snide remark.

One major failure of Gargi is how it depicts the media. Stereotypical representation of media has become a common feature in these kind of films, and Gargi is no different. The character of Aishwarya Lekmi doesn’t bring anything substantial to the tale. The change in her character at the end comes across as lame. There are some other supporting characters too which could have been avoided. These include the uncle character and also the boyfriend of Gargi that we see earlier on. They don’t really help in any way.

The scenes showing the childhood trauma of Gargi are rather inappropriately placed. The intention isn’t wrong but the placement is where it goes horribly wrong. Gargi gives you a sense of deja vu as Sai Pallavi’s love story also had the theme of sexual abuse.

Though Sai Pallavi essays the role of a lower middle class woman with a conviction, which by now we have got accustomed to, the theme of the film has become redundant; it might have reached its expiry date.

Posted on

Vikram: A Masala Treat For The Fans Of Kamal, Fahadh And Vijay

The biggest victory of Lokesh Kangaraj’s Vikram is how he balances the three immensely talented actors. The script has been written in such a way that all three get their moments to shine. In essence, Vikram is a stylish action drama. The first twenty-to thirty minutes of the film are a bit of slog with the overload of the information but as you go along the film starts getting better. Vikram is not as engaging as Karthik’s Kaithi which also belonged to the same genre, but it definitely fares better than the director’s last film Master.

The films begins off the supposed death of Karnan (Kamal Hassan).  Karnan is the father of the martyred cop Prapachan (Kalidas Jayaram) We learn that a series of such killings has been happening, the people responsible for this are a group of masked men. This group calls it their war against the system. To stop these killings, the police chief brings in a black cops team. The head of this team is Amar (Fahadh Fasil). Amar starts digging into the past of Karnan. Vijay Sethupati plays a fearsome drug lord called Santhanam. Santhanam is searching for a shipment that would make him a king pin. Meanwhile, Amar is getting more and more puzzled by the many versions that he hears about Karnan. Was Karnan an alcoholic father grieving over the loss of his son, a womanizer or something more than that? But the bigger question is whether he is really dead.

The most intriguing part of Vikram is the investigation scenes of Amar and his team. These portions keep you hooked as you yourself are also trying to figure out who the actual Karnan is. There isn’t a lot of Kamal Hassan in this part but his presence can still be amply felt, both as an actor and also as a character.

The action part before the interval has a solid twist that makes you look forward for the second half. Post interval the plot becomes more straight faced. Just like Kaithi here too you have a bunch of cops holding against an army of gangsters.

The subplot of Karnan and Prapanchan’s baby gives the second half some emotional undercurrent. These portions are pretty good. Kalidas Jayaram has a small role but the actor does a good job nevertheless.

As I earlier said all the three actors get their moments to shine. Kamal Hassan packs a punch in both the action and the emotional bits. His scenes with the little grandson give some heat touching moments. Fahadh Faasil sails through his role with his usual aplomb. He shines the brightest in the first half. Vijay Sethupati’s Santhanam is an extension of what he did in Master but the actor still makes an impact with his villainous turn. His interactions with the family members raise some chuckle worthy moments.

What pulls down Vikram significantly are the overdose of action. There is no denying that they have been solidly choreographed, but these scenes come too frequently from the middle of the second half.

Also the suspense factor is no longer there once the identity of Karanan is revealed. The film becomes more generic after this in terms of treatment. As a result the film starts feeling very prolonged. The editing department is another minus for Vikram. At least thirty minutes of the film could have been easily chopped off. Because of the excessive length the impact of Surya’s cameo lessens down.

It also doesn’t help that the supporting characters with the exception of Kalidas are mostly gap fillers.  

In a nutshell, watch Vikram if you are a fan of the three actors. But be prepared for all the bloodshed.